Simplest things first, right?
Right. I swapped out the gear selector and it's back in action. I have a theory why the other wasn't selecting gears properly and pushing out the cable. I need to take a look at it.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e7393/e7393efe0152344dbfdcf2d7cd4e8c1c774aad12" alt=""
Welcome to the new TDC forums. You'll need to register to login.
General rules of use: Don't be a jerk. Treat others with respect. No spam. Keep posts on topic of forum. No double posting. Forum will be moderated as needed.